comic prices Even in this country are (considered more or less) awarded prizes for comics, usually in a comic book event selbige something to upgrade. Currently, most commonly the
Max + Moritz Prize of
Comic Salon, the
Sondermann are the Frankfurt Book Fair and the annual ICOM price. Beautiful thing one would think, but every time Gibts Gezerfe and expressions of discontent if the judging. What is?
There are two ways to award prizes, you can tune the audience or a jury. Both have advantages and disadvantages, but ultimately decides argue the personal taste and on the can (not).
The M & M's price has from the perspective of the normal
comic reader clearly lost its prestige, is because there is a price
critics. Here are the titles nominated in part, a little knowledge, and you try hell-bent on the evil "mainstream" to avoid in the pantheon of "art" push forward. This is very clear that the views of critics
and
readers about what is affordable and what is not usually a long way different. Rather it has disqualified itself MMN this year by the award of a title is indeed appear until the day before the awards ceremony in German, but so was omnipresent throughout the event, that there was really no doubt about who gets the prize. suffers
The
Sondermann though, that not by class but by weight, it means what most
sells best has , is nominated and the audience (ie essentially the readers of a particular online newspaper) then vote on who gets the prizes. In itself, a correct method, it has only one thing. The average citizen has no idea about that is usually comic, bw what's in this medium at all. Since
bought what is known , I guess boldly: hardly anyone would know more than half a dozen titles bw cartoon characters. That is so as one would reduce the TV program on
DSDSS and
GZSZ and then say one of two best of what TV shows. Consequently, this time got the price of a title is among connoisseurs as the worst of the whole series.
The
ICOM price, however, has the highest reputation internally - and is strangely less well known. Actually, to be awarded the
ICOM outstanding
Independent Comics just can not now reasonably clear definition of what is and is not independent. Here, indeed, a jury decides, but not consisting of smug / tangled Critics, but mostly from people who make comics too, that have a clue about the matter and contact with the infantry. Sorry, we could here lately is a trend to watch the M & M
closer price. It has a title this year, the
ICOM and the M & M get-price touched the other one or something embarrassing.
Nuja, as they say then bitched in a beautiful regularity in
Forum comic, and always with the same end - would be sure to let the fun times analyzed by a psychologist. Responding to the award involved thin-skinned, and sooner or later the accusation of envy and ignorance (- they respond at all, most jurors are in the greatest comic community at all active). The trouble-makers hold a more or less objectively against it and demand that the whole procedure of the award must be modified to get a "good" results, as should always look like that. At some point in terms of riding around in the comments just to have the last word, and finally someone speaks a word of power ala "Do over! Sit down!" - Until the next award.
the way, some judges I have no idea what they qualified for the job and who they appoint, because sometimes appear to me to say anything.
0 comments:
Post a Comment